Subscribe
Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors
Advertisement

A road to recovery or hidden harm? The mixed blessing of diagnostic labels in mental health

Written by | 19 Nov 2026 | Artificial Intelligence

The way our mind processes, expresses, and responds to emotions and experiences is highly complex. Likewise, the myriad factors that play a role in shaping our mental health, whether internal or external, are just as complex. It is therefore not surprising that receiving a mental health diagnosis can be a very long road that does not always result in a significant improvement in well-being. Whilst for some, a diagnosis is the start of healing, for others, it can involve years of trying to understand what they are experiencing and, unfortunately, sometimes being harmed along the way. So why are we getting it right for some and so wrong for others? Are we relying too heavily on diagnostic frameworks that are not actually fit for all?

The variability in experiences of receiving a diagnosis is partly due to the fact that we are all individuals who perceive things differently and are shaped by different contexts and identities. However, it is also due to the limitations of the diagnostic frameworks that are dominant in psychiatry. Earlier this year however, a strategy for change to the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM) was announced, with an emphasis on greater attention being paid to the causal factors of poor mental health as well as more focus on self-reported wellness. The announced changes have been welcomed by some because they are reflective of a desire to improve and evolve with society. However, many feel that they did not go far enough.

Following on from the announcement of the proposed DSM changes, Open Access journal PLOS Mental Health published a series of articles from Dr Lars Veldmeijer and Professor Jim van Os at Utrecht University, which shed light on what the proposed changes have potentially overlooked, and they do so through both a clinical and lived experience lens.

Initially, Dr Veldmeijer and Professor van Os encourage us to consider diagnosis journeys at an individual level by asking whether we truly understand what happens to a person after they receive a diagnosis. Through a personal account from Dr Veldmeijer and a clinical account from Professor van Os, we see how there is a mismatch between what the patient with the diagnosis is experiencing, and what the mental health professional is aware of. In this particular case, a diagnosis of autism spectrum disorder was given to Dr Veldmeijer. He shares how initially there was a sense of relief from being able to frame his experiences through the lens of this label. However, very soon after, he describes how the diagnosis actually had a detrimental impact on his quality of life as he found himself isolating to avoid overstimulation and anxiety, which, as a result, left Dr Veldmeijer in a position in which he felt that his life had less meaning. His need for help continued to grow, despite having received the diagnosis. We know that elements of this experience are not unique to Dr Veldmeijer. But, are clinicians fully aware of the way that some patients are affected by their diagnosis? As explained by Professor van Os, in the same article, it appears that they are not. As he states: ‘From my experience, such developments are difficult to see as problematic from within the clinical encounter…..Yet, as this testimonial makes clear, the cumulative effect can be a narrowing of agency and a growing distance from one’s earlier ways of being’. Professor van Os explains that the way we currently approach diagnosis journeys means that it is ‘entirely understandable for people with persistent distress to begin reinterpreting their past and reorganising their future around such a powerful narrative. It is also deeply problematic. Psychiatry must, and can, do better.’ This leaves us with a clear message. Those steering changes to the DSM and other diagnostic frameworks must work in partnership with people with lived experience to ensure that changes are made with a better understanding of the potential that receiving a diagnosis can, for some, contribute to one’s suffering. 

In their second article, Dr Veldmeijer and Professor van Os zoom out and examine diagnoses at a societal level. They describe how there are many who experience their pre-diagnostic self-conception in a different way to their post-diagnostic one – whether this is for better or worse. With respect to the latter, they introduce the concept of ‘identity intervention’, which is defined as ‘an intervention that influences the self-concept, expectations, and life story of a person with mental health issues in a potentially harmful way that goes beyond the descriptive function of the diagnostic label’.

As they explain, the internalisation of a clinical diagnosis, whilst sometimes helpful, can also end up shaping identities in restrictive ways, as if a person is living in a metaphorical cage. This is not always the case of course. For many, a diagnosis is the start of healing. But the detrimental effects of a diagnostic label are experienced by enough people that we must have a system that is able to support their journeys differently. This second article was sparked by the publication of the Fonagy review, which, according to the authors, potentially blurs the lines between describing experiences and behaviours and explaining them. They liken this blurring of the boundaries to quicksand, which ends up making the distinction between describing and explaining difficult for mental health professionals and the general public alike. To break this cycle, Dr Veldmeijer and Professor van Os call for us to create spaces in which we can articulate mental distress in ways that do not rely so heavily on clinical terminology. Whilst many instances of mental health struggles will be due to an underlying, diagnosable condition, are we also, in some cases, simply losing sight of what it means to be human?

In their third and final piece on psychiatric diagnoses, Dr Veldmeijer and Professor van Os are joined by Professor Allen Frances, chair of the DSM-IV Task Force, which produced the fourth edition in 1994. Having previously focused on the individual and then on society, the authors now consider the interplay between diagnoses and self-understanding at a time when we live so much of our lives online. This third analysis adds another dimension to the concerns that some have regarding diagnostic frameworks in psychiatry – specifically diagnostic concepts in the age of AI. The potential blurring of boundaries between describing and explaining is especially relevant during a period in which people are more frequently turning to chatbots and online searches to help them explain what they are experiencing. The authors describe their concerns in light of the fact that, whilst AI can be very helpful when it comes to identifying patterns, it is also designed to tell people what they want to hear. Such sycophancy may then further push people towards identifying with diagnostic concepts. As a result, diagnostic language, once reserved for a clinical setting, could spread throughout societies in the absence of regulation. More and more people may shape their identity around a diagnosis, which, as we know from this group of authors, will not always be a beneficial phenomenon. As such, the authors call for AI companies to be accountable and to work with people with lived experience in order to develop and evaluate chatbot designs. A powerful conclusion to the article reminds us that ‘mental health conditions lie on a continuum with ‘normality’; there is no simple divide between ‘us’ and ‘them’. AI chatbots cannot reliably determine where such a distinction should be drawn’. Because of this, when a person is on a journey to understand their mental health struggles and to heal, they need to be asked what matters to them and what they need. Accordingly,  diagnosis should remain a human-led process. As we find ourselves in the age of ‘Dr. AI’, perhaps we need to focus on preventing the human experience from being mislabeled as mentally unwell. 

In short, this series of analytical articles captures the importance of seeking insights from people with lived experience when it comes to shaping diagnostic frameworks in psychiatry. The journey to a diagnosis can be a long one but when we arrive at the diagnosis and the person goes home with this label, a clinician is relatively unaware of how this diagnosis is processed or how other sources of information, such as chatbots, may be encouraging people to continue on a journey of restriction. This is not to say that diagnoses should be abandoned. As much as we become aware of the potential risks of a label, we must remain aware of the benefits of being able to name something and for appropriate treatment options to be identified – especially in the most severe cases.  But we must be cautious when we approach that line between describing and explaining, especially when it comes to general wellness. If we use a diagnosis to explain emotions and behaviors, we overlook the huge range of external factors that contribute to the distress that can often go with being human.

Disclosure: Karli Montague-Cardoso is the Executive Editor of PLOS Mental Health

Newsletter Icon

Subscribe for our mailing list

If you're a healthcare professional you can sign up to our mailing list to receive high quality medical, pharmaceutical and healthcare E-Mails and E-Journals. Get the latest news and information across a broad range of specialities delivered straight to your inbox.

Subscribe

You can unsubscribe at any time using the 'Unsubscribe' link at the bottom of all our E-Mails, E-Journals and publications.